AFP today scooped the news that was going to become at noon EST tomorrow, communicating directly from the White House with the large population already gathered around

Interestingly, this video is now up at from the team at TIGR — Technology, Innovation, and Government Reform:

Interesting quotes from this Beth Noveck (NY Law School), Dan Chenok (GM of Pragmatics, a government IT contractor), Blair Levin (financial firm Stifel Nicolaus and past Chief of Staff for Reed Hundt/FCC), Vivek Kundra (DC’s CTO), and Andrew McLaughlin (Gov’t Affairs from Google):

“Process has trumped outcome.”
Compliance has been more important than innovation
Transparency and opening up the data of government is framed against the Human Genome Project

My first glance at much of this is one of wonderment. The resources that they comment to bring in for all of this are the likes of Google, IBM, policy experts — all the ones who will benefit from these dollars spread around. This reminds me of the oil companies advising the current administration about oil policy, but this time we at least know the names.

Why will government be a better innovator than private enterprise? Should the government be using cutting edge when there are big transfer costs on failed technologies? Will they be pricing in the longer-term costs of some of these transitions? Will we have backup plans and choose technologies that we can find competitive substitutes for? We may develop a stronger technology industrial complex, winding its fingers around government and creating large switching costs in a very non-competitive environment.

This seems like a very large transfer of wealth, not just buying a lot of hardware and services, but also handing over government-gathered data. The positive argument about the data is that it possibly should have already been transparently available. My comment here is that its shifting toward transparency is going to make some folks a lot of money. The ability to make sense of all of this is not in the everyday organization’s toolkit. Those who can dissect data and resell the results are going to have a field day here, selling analysis and toolsets to companies, public policy groups, and the like.

Technology transitions are not neutral. These type of changes cut out companies and transfer wealth to favored players. What will be the parameters for evaluations of success here? How will we deal with the failures that come with innovation? Can we withstand failures in government processes? Do we want our government hanging out at the bleeding edge?

I am not saying, “Let’s not head this way.” I’m concerned at the gleaming glory of tech here. This isn’t reinventing a new Government Genome Project. This is opening the government candy store and offering our friends large handfuls…and needs to be thought through well in terms of objectives, risks, and big issues of structural inequality.

I don’t want us going from the Government of Big Oil to the Government of Big Tech. It needs to be done with some grace, fairness, and dignity — and sincere thinking about the many unintended consequences.

Meanwhile, I’ll be tuning into to see what’s up and how we can help. I’m also going to be watching who is standing in the line to help themselves.

Past Tidbits and Explorations

Reflecting on My SXSW 2016 Journeys

I spoke at SXSW Music again this year on my current favorite topic: Music 20/20 and how we can proactively affect the future. SXSW, however, is not just about speaking. It is about diving deeply into diverse ideas with diverse people. It is one of my annual...

Listening Harder to Me from 2009 and 2011

Happy New Year! I am filtering and sorting the past 3 years of my life in big piles this am. My family is putting up with piles of folders and papers, along with a big cup of coffee, on a portable desk and around my sofa while I watch the 2nd playing of the Rose...

Visually Mapping Your Social Self

In older days, I would Google myself to see how I surfaced.  That's not just an ego thing -- I found many strange things attributed to me.  I research myself, or at least my professional reach. In current days, there are tools that help me "research myself" using...

Pixelating Reality from SXSW Interactive 2014

We enjoyed sharing insights at SXSW Interactive 2014 on this question -- How is smartphone use pixelating reality, blowing it up and turning it into shiftable bits of data so we are making different decisions with its Time and Place? We are in a massive change in...